“Hua Sheng Hai” icw “Kirrixki” [2024] IEHC 182 – 26 March 2024 (Mr Justice Denis McDonald)

Following a collision off Ireland between the laden, 620,000 GRT bulk carrier “Hua Sheng Hai” and the 320 GRT fishing vessel “Kirrixki”, the Irish Court found that “Kirrixki” failed to keep a (or any) look out; she was not (as claimed) lowering nets but slow-steaming to new waters, then suddenly changed course and accelerated just prior to the collision. She was not the stand-on vessel, but in any event was in breach of Colregs for not holding her course and speed, and was the major cause of the collision. “Hua Sheng Hai” whilst not required to change course, nevertheless failed to take timely action to avoid unexpected and sudden danger. Liability was set at 85% “Kirrixki” 15% “Hua Sheng Hai”.